Educational tool, not legal or tax advice. Use the replacement forms your carrier and agency require; this worksheet organizes the facts and does not replace them. The decision and the written basis are the agent's.
| Line | Old contract | New contract |
|---|---|---|
| Account value | ||
| Cash surrender value (as of a date) | ||
| Surrender charge today | ||
| Surrender charge after the next anniversary | ||
| Market value adjustment estimate (or "ask the carrier") | ||
| Free withdrawal terms; do they apply to an exchange? | ||
| Credited and uncredited index interest at the exit date | ||
| Unvested bonus on the old contract | ||
| New surrender schedule | ||
| New bonus: vesting and forfeiture on early surrender | ||
| Rider fee and other charges; premium tax | ||
| Rate hold: how long, and what if funding is late | ||
| Guaranteed yearly advantage in dollars |
Break-even years = cost to leave the old contract / yearly dollar advantage, taken from the guaranteed column. Then compare surrender values year by year, and test waiting one anniversary.
Each guarantee is a promise of the issuing insurer and depends on its claims-paying ability.
Write at least three reasons the client might keep the contract, and answer each, whichever way the final answer goes.
Source: Annuities Genius, The Annuity Replacement File, annuitiesgenius.com/blog/1035-exchange-annuity-replacement-rules-for-agents. Sources last opened 2026-11-05.