Annuity replacement worksheet

Educational tool, not legal or tax advice. Use the replacement forms your carrier and agency require; this worksheet organizes the facts and does not replace them. The decision and the written basis are the agent's.

1. Tax test

2. Money test

LineOld contractNew contract
Account value
Cash surrender value (as of a date)
Surrender charge today
Surrender charge after the next anniversary
Market value adjustment estimate (or "ask the carrier")
Free withdrawal terms; do they apply to an exchange?
Credited and uncredited index interest at the exit date
Unvested bonus on the old contract
New surrender schedule
New bonus: vesting and forfeiture on early surrender
Rider fee and other charges; premium tax
Rate hold: how long, and what if funding is late
Guaranteed yearly advantage in dollars

Break-even years = cost to leave the old contract / yearly dollar advantage, taken from the guaranteed column. Then compare surrender values year by year, and test waiting one anniversary.

3. Guarantee test (dollar value of each, from the contract and the carrier's written answer)

Each guarantee is a promise of the issuing insurer and depends on its claims-paying ability.

4. Paper test

Keep test

Write at least three reasons the client might keep the contract, and answer each, whichever way the final answer goes.

Source: Annuities Genius, The Annuity Replacement File, annuitiesgenius.com/blog/1035-exchange-annuity-replacement-rules-for-agents. Sources last opened 2026-11-05.