Skip to the lesson

"Average return" is not what you get: order matters

Two retirees with the same average return can end far apart when money comes out. The order of the returns decides.

Do it in Genius

All cases your client Simulator Run in GrantAI Worst market Present

Practice Client, 16 Nov 2026: worst stretch 1929 to 1963. Deepest cut in a year: 53% on savings alone, 35% with lifetime income.

Rates change every day, so yours will differ.

Open your clients in Genius (opens the app in a new tab)

In the app: CRM → All cases

  1. 1.

    Two retirees start with $1,000,000 and take $60,000 at the start of each year. Same six returns, opposite order.

    Returns in order: -20%, -10%, +5%, +10%, +15%, +20%. The average is about 3.3%.

  2. 2.

    Bad years first: about $651,000 is left after six years. Good years first: about $835,000. Same average, about $184,000 apart.

    Why: the $60,000 comes out each year. With no withdrawals, the order changes nothing.

  3. 3.

    On your client, click Simulator in the left card. Leave Markets on Worst & typical and click Run in GrantAI.

    Short from
    The age when savings run out. On the lifetime income panel, the annuity income keeps paying.

    Point at the Worst market card, then click Present. Compare Deepest cut in a year on both panels.

You're done when you can say why order matters and read the deepest yearly cut on both panels.
Watch out: Never say which years are coming. The worst card is the worst stretch on record: show the typical card too.
Sources